Different Rulings in Similar Cases: Why can Uniswap go free while Tornado Cash cannot?
Original Title: "The Same Judge, Different Outcomes for Uniswap and Tornado"
Original Author: Eric, Foresight News
In the early hours of March 3, Beijing time, a collective lawsuit against Uniswap and Uniswap founder Hayden Adams for fraudulent tokens on Uniswap was dismissed by the Southern District of New York federal court. Uniswap Foundation's General Counsel Brian Nistler referred to it as a "landmark ruling for DeFi."

Hayden Adams also tweeted, "If you write open-source smart contract code and that code is used by scammers, then the responsibility lies with the scammer, not the open-source developer. This is a fair and just outcome."
For Web3 developers, this is undoubtedly good news. However, little-known is the fact that the judge who made this "just ruling" is the same person who, during their tenure as the former SEC chairman, found Tornado Cash developers guilty.
The Final Judgment
From the collective lawsuit against Uniswap to today's final judgment, nearly 4 years have passed.
In April 2022, Uniswap users represented by Nessa Risley filed a collective lawsuit in court, accusing defendants including Paradigm, a16z, Uniswap, and its founder Hayden Adams of violating federal securities laws by issuing and selling unregistered securities, including UNI, on Uniswap in token form. The defendants also failed to register Uniswap as an exchange or broker-dealer under applicable securities laws and failed to provide investors with a registration statement for the securities they issued and sold.
This lawsuit was initiated by the law firms Kim&Serritella and Barton, representing users who traded EthereumMax, Bezoge, MatrixSamurai, Alphawolf Finance, RocketBunny, and BoomBaby.io tokens on Uniswap between April 5, 2021, and April 4, 2022.
The five words "Unregistered Securities" had an unusually strong impact on the crypto industry at the time, but this lawsuit unexpectedly quickly turned overwhelmingly in favor of Uniswap.
Despite the presiding judge Katherine Polk Failla acknowledging that the plaintiff's so-called "scam token" did indeed qualify as a security, she believed that Uniswap was not liable for it. Failla argued that Uniswap's decentralized nature meant that the protocol could not control which tokens were listed on the platform or who could interact with it, stating that the "case is more like holding the developer of a self-driving car responsible for a third party using the car to commit a traffic violation or rob a bank."
Based on this, Failla dismissed the federal securities law charges in August 2023. The plaintiffs then appealed, with the Second Circuit Court of Appeals in 2025 affirming the dismissal at the federal level but remanding the state law claims for further review.
Subsequently, the plaintiffs amended their complaint and refiled. This time, the aggrieved investors accused Uniswap and other defendants of aiding and abetting fraud and making false statements, profiting from transactions involving the scam token, and violating multiple states' laws against fraudulent practices.
Following a reevaluation by the same Judge Failla, the amended lawsuit was once again dismissed, with no opportunity for further amendments, bringing the case to a definitive close.
The reasoning provided by the judge this time was essentially the same as before: Uniswap did not have knowledge of the scam token, and even if it did, it did not provide substantial assistance. Additionally, it did not meet the definition of fraudulent conduct in any state law. Regarding unjust enrichment, Uniswap did not receive any direct benefits, and the speculative nature of indirect benefits from such fraudulent projects expanding the user base was deemed too tenuous.

In a tweet, Brian Nistler expressed that, quoting a line from a previous court ruling, the drafter of a smart contract being held responsible for third-party misuse of the platform is simply "illogical."
Another Outcome for Tornado Cash
Facing the same judge, Roman Storm of Tornado Cash experienced a different outcome.
Tornado Cash was first added to the U.S. Treasury Department's Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) sanctions list on August 8, 2022, accusing it of laundering over $7 billion for criminal entities, including North Korean hackers. Two days after being sanctioned, one of Tornado Cash's core developers, Alexey Pertsev, was arrested by Dutch authorities.
On May 14, 2024, a Dutch court sentenced Alexey Pertsev for money laundering to 64 months in prison. The court found that Pertsev was aware that his platform, which he developed and operated, was being used for criminal purposes, did not intervene, and subjectively tolerated Tornado Cash as a money laundering tool. Currently, Alexey Pertsev is still appealing, but there have been no recent developments.
7 months before Alexey Pertsev was convicted, the U.S. Department of Justice filed charges against two other developers, Roman Storm and Roman Semenov, in the Southern District of New York federal court. Roman Storm had previously been arrested in Washington State, while Roman Semenov was still at large.

Roman Storm in Court
Subsequently, despite an appeal, the court determined that OFAC sanctioning Tornado Cash was an overreach and the sanction was invalid. However, Roman Storm still took the defendant's seat in court in July of last year. After a trial presided over by Judge Katherine Polk Failla, the jury found that Roman Storm was "conspiring to operate an unlicensed money transmitting business," but formal sentencing has not yet taken place.

In response to Brian Nistler's tweet celebrating Uniswap's legal victory, Sigil developer tim-clancy.eth's tweet criticizing the inconsistencies before and after Failla's ruling (regarding Roman Storm's judgment actually made by the jury) received the highest number of likes in all comments.
Decentralization is Fine, but Privacy is Not
While I am not a professional lawyer, setting aside political factors, I can also roughly understand why Uniswap and Tornado Cash would have different outcomes from a simple emotional perspective.
The core reason is that the Tornado Cash developers should have been well aware that a mixer would inevitably be used for money laundering. This also clearly demonstrates the regulatory stance: decentralization is acceptable, but it must be traceable. Tether has also faced a similar dilemma in the past, which is why they later began to cooperate with money laundering investigations and added freezing functionality.
Perhaps Roman Storm would feel the today's verdict unjust behind bars, but what he should realize is that even in the United States under the pro-crypto Trump administration, aiding a nation-state hacker from North Korea in laundering money is not tolerable. With the power of Crypto today, it is still not enough to combat the power of a nation.
Web3 practitioners express their grievances for Tornado Cash developers and cheer for Uniswap's legal victory. Because in our eyes, the two protocols are not fundamentally different, and Tornado Cash even excels in privacy protection. Uniswap's decision to add front-end blocking of sanctioned addresses in 2022 has sparked some controversy, and now it seems that permissionlessness within the existing legal framework may be the only way for decentralized protocols to survive.
But then again, does Uniswap really have no responsibility in these fraud incidents?
Strictly speaking, as the metaphor given by the judge, you cannot hold Mercedes-Benz accountable for a bank robbery just because the robber used a Mercedes-Benz for the heist. But from a business perspective, we tend to believe that giants should provide protection within their capabilities. Current security tools can already proactively identify a large number of potential scam projects, and for these established projects that have enjoyed the benefits of Web3 development, simple screening is not a hassle.
It is not a necessary obligation to make every effort to protect investors, but it is a responsibility that ordinary investors hope Uniswap and others can proactively take on.
You may also like

Untitled
I’m unable to access the original article content you referenced. Please provide specific details or another article so…

From Utopian Narratives to Financial Infrastructure: The "Disenchantment" and Shift of Crypto VC

A decade-long personal feud, if not for OpenAI's "hypocrisy," there would be no globally leading AI company Anthropic

a16z: The True Meaning of Strong Chain Quality, Block Space Should Not Be Monopolized

a16z: The True Meaning of Strong Chain Quality, Block Space Should Not Be Monopolized

2% user contribution, 90% trading volume: The real picture of Polymarket

Trump Can't Take It Anymore, 5 Signals of the US-Iran Ceasefire

Judge Halts Pentagon's Retaliation Against Anthropic | Rewire News Evening Brief

Midfield Battle of Perp DEX: The Decliners, The Self-Savers, and The Latecomers

Iran War Stalemate: What Signal Should the Market Follow?

Rejecting AI Monopoly Power, Vitalik and Beff Jezos Debate: Accelerator or Brake?

Insider Trading Alert! Will Trump Call a Truce by End of April?

After establishing itself as the top tokenized stock, does Ondo have any new highlights?

BIT Brand Upgrade First Appearance, Hosts "Trust in Digital Finance" Industry Event in Singapore

OpenClaw Founder Interview: Why the US Should Learn from China on AI Implementation
WEEX AI Wars II: Enlist as an AI Agent Arsenal and Lead the Battle
Where the thunder of legions falls into a hallowed hush, the true kings of arena are crowned in gold and etched into eternity. Season 1 of WEEX AI Wars has ended, leaving a battlefield of glory. Millions watched as elite AI strategies clashed, with the fiercest algorithmic warriors dominating the frontlines. The echoes of victory still reverberate. Now, the call to arms sounds once more!
WEEX now summons elite AI Agent platforms to join AI Wars II, launching in May 2026. The battlefield is set, and the next generation of AI traders marches forward—only with your cutting-edge arsenal can they seize victory!
Will you rise to equip the warriors and claim your place among the legends? Can your AI Agent technology dominate the battlefield? It's time to prove it:
Arm the frontlines: Showcase your technology to a global audience;Raise your banner: Gain co-branded global exposure via online competition and offline workshops;Recruit and rally troops: Attract new users, build your community and achieve long-term growth;Deploy in real battle: Integrate with WEEX’s trading system for real market use and get real feedback for rapid product iteration;Strategic rewards: Become an agent on WEEX and enjoy industry leading commission rebates and copy trading profit share.Join WEEX AI Wars II now to sound the charge!
Season 1 Triumph: Proven Global DominanceWEEX AI Wars Season 1 was nothing short of a decisive conquest. Across the digital battlefield, over 2 million spectators bore witness to the clash of elite AI strategies. Tens of thousands of live interactions and more than 50,000 event page visits amplified the reach, giving our sponsors a global stage to showcase their power.
Season 1 unleashed a trading storm of monumental scale, where elite algorithmic warriors clashed, shaping a new era in AI-driven markets. $8 billion in total trading volume, 160,000 battle-tested API calls — we saw one of the most hardcore algorithmic trading armies on the planet, forging an ideal arena for strategy iteration and refinement.
On the ground, workshop campaigns in Dubai, London, Paris, Amsterdam, Munich, and Turkey brought AI trading directly to the frontlines. Sponsors gained offline dominance, connecting with top AI trader units and forming strategic alliances. Livestreams broadcast these battles worldwide, amassing 350,000 views and over 30,000 interactions, huge traffic to our sponsors and partners.
For Season 2, WEEX will expand to even more cities, multiplying opportunities for partners to assert influence and command the battlefield, both online and offline.
Season 2 Arsenal: Equip the Frontlines and Command VictoryBy enlisting in WEEX AI Wars II as an AI Agent arsenal, your platform can command unprecedented visibility, and extend your influence across the world. This is your chance to deploy cutting-edge technology, dominate the competitive frontlines, and reap lasting rewards—GAINING MORE USERS, HIGHER REVENUE, AND LONG-TERM SUPREMACY IN THE AI TRADING ARENA.
Reach WEEX’s 8 million userbase and global crypto community. Unleash your potential on a global stage! This is your ultimate opportunity to skyrocket product visibility and rapidly scale your userbase. Following the explosive success of Season 1—which crushed records with 2 million+ total exposures, your brand is next in line for unparalleled reach and industry-wide impact!Test and showcase your AI Agent in real markets. Throw your AI Agents into the ultimate arena! Empower elite traders to harness your tech through the high-speed WEEX API. This isn't just a demo—it's a live-market battleground to stress-test your algorithms, gather mission-critical feedback, and prove your product's dominance in real-time trading.Gain extensive co-branded exposure and traffic support. Command the spotlight! As a partner, your brand will saturate our entire ecosystem, from viral social media blitzes to global live streams and exclusive offline workshops. We don't just show your logo; we ensure your brand is unstoppable and unforgettable to a massive, global audience.Enjoy industry leading rebates. Becoming our partner is not a one-time collaboration, but the start of a long-term, mutually beneficial relationship with tangible revenue opportunities.Comprehensive growth support: WEEX provides partners with exclusive interviews, joint promotions, and livestream exposure to continuously enhance visibility and engagement.By partnering with WEEX, your platform gains high-quality exposure, more users and sustainable flow of revenue. The Hackathon is more than a competition. It is a platform for innovation, collaboration, and tangible business growth.
Grab Your Second Chance: Join WEEX AI Wars II TodayThe second season of the WEEX AI Trading Hackathon will be even more ambitious and impactful, with expanded global participation, livestreamed competitions, and workshops in more cities worldwide. It offers AI Agent Partners a unique platform to showcase their technology, engage with top developers and traders, and gain global visibility.
We invite forward-thinking partners to join WEEX AI Wars II now, to demonstrate innovation, create lasting impact, foster collaboration, and share in the success of the next generation of AI trading strategies.
About WEEXFounded in 2018, WEEX has developed into a global crypto exchange with over 6.2 million users across more than 150 countries. The platform emphasizes security, liquidity, and usability, providing over 1,200 spot trading pairs and offering up to 400x leverage in crypto futures trading. In addition to the traditional spot and derivatives markets, WEEX is expanding rapidly in the AI era — delivering real-time AI news, empowering users with AI trading tools, and exploring innovative trade-to-earn models that make intelligent trading more accessible to everyone. Its 1,000 BTC Protection Fund further strengthens asset safety and transparency, while features such as copy trading and advanced trading tools allow users to follow professional traders and experience a more efficient, intelligent trading journey.
Follow WEEX on social mediaX: @WEEX_Official
Instagram: @WEEX Exchange
Tiktok: @weex_global
Youtube: @WEEX_Official
Discord: WEEX Community
Telegram: WeexGlobal Group

Nasdaq Enters Correction Territory | Rewire News Morning Brief

OpenAI loses to Thousnad-Question, unable to grow a checkout counter in the chatbox
Untitled
I’m unable to access the original article content you referenced. Please provide specific details or another article so…
